Diagnostic guide
Synology 'Volume Crashed' or 'Degraded' Storage Pool – What To Do Before You Touch Anything
Symptom
DSM reports a storage pool as Degraded or a volume as Crashed, often after a drive failed, the wrong drive was pulled, or an update.
The two words mean different things. Per Synology's documentation, Degraded means the pool is running without full redundancy and can usually be repaired by replacing the failed drive, with repair starting from Storage Manager. Crashed is more serious: Synology says it cannot be repaired by the user and recommends contacting Synology Technical Support, and advises keeping the drives in the same order they were in when it crashed. In both cases the first rule is the same: do not pull drives or start rebuilds until you know what failed.
Do not
STOP - Do Not Rearrange or Rebuild
- Do not pull and re-seat disks in random order
- Do not start a Repair onto a replacement while another disk looks weak
- Do not run mdadm --create or force-assemble commands over SSH
- Do not delete the pool or volume and recreate it
- Do not reset DSM or reinstall it to 'clear' the error
Why this matters: Synology notes that Repair does not guarantee data on a crashed volume will be recovered, and that disk order matters. A rebuild reads every remaining disk heavily; if a second disk is already weak, it can fail during the rebuild and take the array with it.
Cause
Most Likely Causes
- 01
A Disk Dropped Out of the Pool
High LikelihoodOne drive failed or disconnected. A single drive loss on a redundant pool shows as Degraded.
- 02
The Wrong Drive Was Pulled
Medium LikelihoodA healthy drive was removed in place of the failed one, so two members were missing at once.
- 03
Second Weak Disk
Medium LikelihoodAnother disk with bad sectors fails during stress and the pool loses redundancy beyond what it can handle.
- 04
Power Loss or Update Interruption
Less CommonAn unclean shutdown or interrupted DSM update left the array in an inconsistent state.
What to do
Safe Diagnostic Checks
These checks are non-destructive and safe to perform. Follow them exactly as written.
Read, don't act
- 01In Storage Manager, note the pool and volume status, and which disk bays are flagged
- 02Open HDD/SSD and read each drive's status and health info, without starting a test that stresses a weak disk
- 03Photograph the screen and the physical bay order, and label every drive with its bay number
- 04Export or screenshot the DSM log entries from the time it began
Information gathering only. Do not click Repair, Deactivate or Remove.
Secure what is still readable
- 01If the shares still open (Degraded), copy the most important data to another drive or machine
- 02If a drive was pulled by mistake and you know which, do not do anything else before reading Synology's guidance for reinserting it
- 03If the volume is Crashed, power down in an orderly way and keep the drives in order
Escalate
When Professional Recovery Is Required
You should seek professional data recovery if any of these apply:
- The volume is Crashed
- More than one disk is missing or flagged
- A repair or rebuild has failed or stalled
- The wrong drive was pulled and the order is uncertain
- The NAS holds the only copy of business or family data
Process
Our Recovery Process
- Turnaround Time
- 3-7 business days
- Success Rate
- Assessed in the free evaluation; depends on the damage
What happens when you bring your drive to us:
- 01Free evaluation: record disk order, RAID or SHR layout and the state of each member
- 02Image every member disk read-only; the NAS is not rebuilt
- 03Reconstruct the array virtually from the images
- 04Mount the volume (Btrfs or ext4) and check file system integrity on the copy
- 05Extract your data
- 06Return the data on new media
FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions
Related
Related Guides
- 01
RAID 5 Rebuild Failed with 2 Drives Offline
Your RAID 5 array has failed during rebuild or shows multiple drives offline. - 02
Synology NAS Blinking Blue Light – Data Recovery
Your Synology NAS is stuck with a blinking blue status light and won't boot normally. - 03
WD My Cloud Yellow Light Flashing – Data Recovery
Your WD My Cloud NAS has a solid or flashing yellow/amber front LED.
Background reading
Free diagnosis
Need Professional Data Recovery?
Free Diagnosis • No Recovery, No Charge
Our certified technicians have recovered thousands of drives with these exact symptoms. Get your free evaluation today.
- 97% Success Rate
- Across all device types
- ISO-5 Cleanroom
- Class 100 certified facility
- 24/7 Emergency
- Available for critical cases