Diagnostic guide
Dell PowerEdge PERC 'Foreign Configuration' After Two Drives Drop From a RAID 5
Symptom
Your PowerEdge server boots to the PERC screen and shows drives as Foreign, with the choice to Import or Clear the foreign configuration.
A RAID 5 survives one missing drive. When a second drops, or a drive drops and then comes back, the controller no longer trusts what is written on those drives and labels them Foreign. Dell's article on this subject says to try Import first, and, if more than one disk went foreign, to keep the disk that went foreign last because it holds the latest data. It treats Clear only as a fallback after an import fails. The menu makes the two look equal. They are not.
Do not
STOP - Do Not Clear the Foreign Configuration or Start a Rebuild
- Do not choose Clear Foreign Configuration
- Do not delete and recreate the virtual disk
- Do not run Fast Init or Full Init on any virtual disk
- Do not force a drive Online, or rebuild from the drive that dropped first
- Do not reseat all the drives and power on 'to see what happens'
Why this matters: Dell's article says the last disk to go foreign has the latest data, which is why it should be the one kept; the drives that dropped earlier hold older information. A rebuild or import from the wrong member, or a clear, writes over the configuration that describes how your data is laid out. Dell's own text gives no assurance about what is lost on Clear, so treat it as irreversible.
Cause
Most Likely Causes
- 01
A Second Drive Dropped After the First
High LikelihoodRAID 5 tolerates one failure. Once a second member drops, the array fails and the controller flags the drives as Foreign.
- 02
Drives Dropped Because of a Backplane, Cable or Power Issue
Medium LikelihoodDrives that went offline together may be healthy but unseen. This is the best case, but it still needs a careful order of steps.
- 03
Controller Lost or Mismatched Its Stored Configuration
Medium LikelihoodDell's article describes foreign disks as ones whose configuration is unknown to the controller or does not match its current one, which can follow a controller swap or cache loss.
- 04
Genuine Drive Failure on Two Members
Medium LikelihoodTwo worn drives of the same age and batch is a common pattern. This calls for hardware work on the drives before reassembly.
What to do
Safe Diagnostic Checks
These checks are non-destructive and safe to perform. Follow them exactly as written.
Record what the controller sees, without choosing anything
- 01Photograph the PERC screen: virtual disk state, each physical disk's slot, state (Foreign, Failed, Online) and size
- 02If the server is up, record the controller log or Lifecycle Controller log; Dell notes the timestamps show which disk went foreign last
- 03Note the RAID level and how many drives were in the array
- 04Do not press Import, Clear or any initialise option
Preserve the physical layout
- 01Power the server down cleanly
- 02Label each drive with its slot number before removal, if you remove any
- 03Do not swap drives between slots
- 04Stop here and keep the drives as they are
If any drive has already been replaced or an import has already been attempted, say so; it changes the plan.
Escalate
When Professional Recovery Is Required
You should seek professional data recovery if any of these apply:
- Two or more drives are Foreign or Failed on a RAID 5
- You are unsure which drive went offline first
- An import, clear or rebuild has already been tried
- The array holds production, database or virtual machine data
- A drive is clicking, missing or very slow
Process
Our Recovery Process
- Turnaround Time
- 3-7 business days
- Success Rate
- Assessed in the free evaluation; depends on the damage
What happens when you bring your drive to us:
- 01Free evaluation: record the slot order, controller state and every drive's condition
- 02Image each member drive, repairing weak ones at the hardware level first
- 03Determine the array's geometry and the order in which members dropped
- 04Reassemble the array virtually from the images, never from the originals
- 05Mount the volume read-only, verify databases and virtual machine files, and extract them
- 06Return the data on new media
FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions
Related
Related Guides
- 01
RAID 5 Rebuild Failed with 2 Drives Offline
Your RAID 5 array has failed during rebuild or shows multiple drives offline. - 02
QNAP RAID Degraded or Storage Pool Lost – Do Not Rebuild Yet
Your QNAP reports a degraded RAID group, a read-only volume, or the storage pool has disappeared after a drive failed or a firmware update. - 03
Synology 'Volume Crashed' or 'Degraded' Storage Pool – What To Do Before You Touch Anything
DSM reports a storage pool as Degraded or a volume as Crashed, often after a drive failed, the wrong drive was pulled, or an update.
Background reading
Free diagnosis
Need Professional Data Recovery?
Free Diagnosis • No Recovery, No Charge
Our certified technicians have recovered thousands of drives with these exact symptoms. Get your free evaluation today.
- 97% Success Rate
- Across all device types
- ISO-5 Cleanroom
- Class 100 certified facility
- 24/7 Emergency
- Available for critical cases