Diagnostic guide
QNAP RAID Degraded or Storage Pool Lost – Do Not Rebuild Yet
Symptom
Your QNAP reports a degraded RAID group, a read-only volume, or the storage pool has disappeared after a drive failed or a firmware update.
QNAP's own guidance for a degraded RAID 1, 5 or 6 is to replace the faulty disk and let it rebuild, and for a RAID group that has turned read-only to back up first because replacing a disk can make the group inactive. A rebuild reads every remaining disk end to end, and that is when a second weak disk often fails. People also try Linux commands copied from forums; the wrong one rewrites the array's records. If the volume is still readable, copying it off is the safest thing you can do.
Do not
STOP - Do Not Rebuild, Re-create or Initialise Anything
- Do not replace a disk if the group is read-only or inactive
- Do not start a rebuild onto a replacement while any other disk shows errors
- Do not run mdadm --create or force an assembly from copied forum commands
- Do not create a new storage pool or initialise the disks
- Do not remove or reorder disks to 'test' them
Why this matters: QNAP's disk-error guidance says that for a read-only degraded group, replacing a disk usually will not fix it and can make the group inactive; the instruction is to copy data to another device without changing disks. If the data cannot be reached, QNAP says not to change or remove the disks. A rebuild puts heavy read load on already worn disks.
Cause
Most Likely Causes
- 01
One Disk Failed, Others Are Ageing
High LikelihoodDisks in a NAS are usually the same age and wear together. The first failure is often followed by another during rebuild.
- 02
More Disks Failed Than the RAID Level Tolerates
Medium LikelihoodQNAP states that when faulty disks exceed the group's fault tolerance, the group turns read-only or inactive. Replacing a disk does not fix that.
- 03
Pool Metadata or Firmware Issue
Medium LikelihoodA power loss or an update can leave the storage pool's records inconsistent, so the pool shows as lost while the disks hold the data.
- 04
Rebuild That Keeps Skipping
Medium LikelihoodQNAP notes that a rebuild which keeps skipping may mean another disk is faulty, and says to back up your data as soon as possible.
What to do
Safe Diagnostic Checks
These checks are non-destructive and safe to perform. Follow them exactly as written.
Find out whether you can still read the data
- 01Open QTS and look at Storage & Snapshots: note the RAID level, which disk is flagged and the status of each disk
- 02Photograph the screen, including SMART status for every disk
- 03If File Station still opens the shares, copy the most important folders to a separate device now
- 04Copy, do not move, and stop if the NAS becomes unresponsive
If the NAS shows the group as read-only, QNAP's guidance is to back up to another device without changing the disks. Do not hot-swap anything first.
Record, then leave the disks alone
- 01Write down the bay number of every disk and its serial number
- 02Do not remove disks to check labels while the NAS is running
- 03Check that you have somewhere with enough free space for a full copy
- 04Stop here if the pool is lost or the data is not reachable; QNAP says not to change or remove the disks in that case
Escalate
When Professional Recovery Is Required
You should seek professional data recovery if any of these apply:
- The storage pool or volume is gone or inactive
- More than one disk is flagged, or SMART warnings appear on several
- A rebuild has started and keeps failing or skipping
- RAID 0 or JBOD with a failed member, where there is no redundancy
- A disk was already replaced or commands were run from a forum post
Process
Our Recovery Process
- Turnaround Time
- 3-7 business days
- Success Rate
- Assessed in the free evaluation; depends on the damage
What happens when you bring your drive to us:
- 01Free evaluation: record the bay order, RAID level and every disk's condition
- 02Image each member disk separately through a read-only path, repairing weak disks at the hardware level first
- 03Work out the array's layout and reassemble it virtually from the images
- 04Mount the volume read-only and extract your shares
- 05Verify files open and return them on new media
FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions
Related
Related Guides
- 01
RAID 5 Rebuild Failed with 2 Drives Offline
Your RAID 5 array has failed during rebuild or shows multiple drives offline. - 02
Synology 'Volume Crashed' or 'Degraded' Storage Pool – What To Do Before You Touch Anything
DSM reports a storage pool as Degraded or a volume as Crashed, often after a drive failed, the wrong drive was pulled, or an update. - 03
Synology Shows 'Migratable' or 'Not Installed' After a DSM Update or a Move
After a failed DSM update, a power cut or moving drives to another unit, find.synology.com or Synology Assistant shows your NAS as Migratable or Not Installed and asks you to install DSM. - 04
WD My Cloud EX2 Ultra Unreachable, Shares Gone or Volume Failure After a Firmware Update
Your WD My Cloud EX2 Ultra disappeared from the network, the shares are missing, or the dashboard reports a volume failure after a firmware update.
Background reading
Free diagnosis
Need Professional Data Recovery?
Free Diagnosis • No Recovery, No Charge
Our certified technicians have recovered thousands of drives with these exact symptoms. Get your free evaluation today.
- 97% Success Rate
- Across all device types
- ISO-5 Cleanroom
- Class 100 certified facility
- 24/7 Emergency
- Available for critical cases